Preventing LGD Failure - Meeting Your LGD’s Needs 

It can be confusing, especially for new owners of livestock guardian dogs (LGDs) to sort out which information to follow as oftentimes the advice they hear is contradictory. For example “never bring them in the house and don’t handle them a lot” versus “bring them
inside where they feel safe and let the puppy/dog hang out with you”. So, how about we take a look at how these dogs have been raised for thousands of years in their countries of origin? After all, the shepherds in those countries truly needed these dogs for survival so
in my opinion, they are the experts.

One major problem with many LGDs is that they are difficult to contain, resulting in the dogs leaving their pastures and leaving their livestock behind, leaving the livestock vulnerable to predators and the dog at risk of being hit by cars or shot but other livestock owners. Why a dog starts leaving their pasture and livestock can of course have many reasons. So here is one - every dog has basic needs. If these needs are met, the dog is content. If these needs aren't met, the dog will try to find a way on its own to have those needs met.

What are those basic needs?

1. Food and Water

This may sound simple, but it is important to make sure that the dog, and especially a puppy, has easy access to food and water, without being intimidated, crowded or interrupted by livestock or other dogs when the dog or puppy wants to eat or drink.

2. Safety

Dogs, and especially young puppies, have an instinctual need to feel safe. That means they will stay close to their mother, other adult dogs or humans, because they know that they are vulnerable and cannot protect themselves from danger. The same is true for single LGDs, when faced with major predators or large numbers of predators, the single dog will look for a way to stay safe himself. In addition to that, puppies and young dogs can go through fear periods during which they can be very fearful even of situations that they were previously okay with.

If you observe a puppy, or any LGD, being worried about livestock, being left alone in the pasture or barn, afraid of certain noises or equipment, don’t ignore it, as that means that dog’s basic need for feeling safe is not met. Try to meet that need.

3. Comfort and Shelter

The LGD needs to have adequate protection from bad weather, heat and cold as well as from parasites and flies. They also need to receive adequate grooming, hands on inspections to check for mats, injuries, infections, pain or other physical problems that would affect their comfort level. A dog that does not receive adequate care may
display behaviors such as aggression towards livestock, other dogs or humans. The dog may also try to escape its pasture or become destructive. Flies for example can make a dog miserable and he may seek for ways to get away from an area that is infested with flies.

4. Enrichment

Enrichment to prevent boredom and provide both mental and physical exercise is important for any dog. Play for example is very important for LGD puppies. Through play the puppy learns and practices skills needed to fight a predator. If you do not have another dog your puppy can play with, you will have to be creative to meet the dog’s/puppy’s needs for play time and exercise. Take walks
with the dog/puppy around your property, Offer a variety of toys to provide opportunities for your dog/puppy to use its teeth, use its nose, practice a shake and a pounce, as well as tugging, pulling and chasing toys. Enrichment is not just entertainment, it allows your dog/puppy to develop confidence and skills.

Keep in mind that if a dog’s needs for mental and physical exercise are not met, he may look for it on the other side of the fence. Once escape behavior starts and the dog is being reinforced by having fun exploring, it can become very difficult if not impossible to convince the dog to stay in its pasture.

5. Social Interaction

Social interactions are crucial for a dog’s development and mental health. Most dogs thrive on companionship. In the case of working LGDs, the companions that the dog spends most of his time with are usually the livestock and other dogs. Observe your dog and make sure his needs for companionship are met. If there are other dogs, how do they get along? Do they hang out near each other, do they work as a team, do the play with each other? If the dog has livestock for companionship, are there interactions with livestock that show they like to hang out with each other?

If a dog has no satisfying social interactions with livestock or other dogs he will feel lonely and may escape the pasture to be near his humans to try and meet his needs for social interactions. If you recognize your dog’s need for social interactions are not met in the pasture, make plans to meet those needs before the dog gets into a habit of getting out of the pasture to look for companionship. It is much easier to prevent problem behaviors than to fix them. Some training, hanging out together, grooming, coming along for chores go a long way in making the dog feel more content.

Think Ahead:

Before bringing home an LGD of any age make sure that you have a plan to prevent the dog from getting out of fenced areas. This needs to start with the breeder who should contain the puppies in a way that they don’t learn to get under/over or squeeze through
fencing. Once dogs have learned they can overcome simple obstacles like fences, they never forget and they can be extremely resourceful in overcoming such obstacles.

Back to our LGDs countries of origin

For the most part, the human shepherds live with the stock and the dogs. Many times puppies are whelped and spend their first few months in the village in the yard of their owner’s home, at other times they are whelped and raised out on the pasture with their
human shepherds and the rest of the working dog team. They are free to explore and play, but they are never left alone, they always enjoy the security and social interactions with humans, livestock and other dogs. The human shepherds interact with and handle their
dogs. There are no rules that the dogs can’t hang out near the campfire or where the shepherds are resting. The shepherds have confidence in their dogs’ intelligence and superior senses to do their job. In this environment puppies slowly grow into their role as
working dogs as they always have the backup of more experienced dogs.

Also in many cases the shepherds, livestock and the LGDs return to their villages in the winter months where livestock is being penned and the LGDs hang out in the barnyard. Thus they live a different life in the winter than they do in the warmer months.

Keeping all of this in mind. It’s best to keep an open mind and not insist on rigid ideas of
how an LGD should live or be raised. They are quite flexible and adaptable and sometimes we just need to sit back and observe and let the dogs tell us what they are good at and how they go about getting the job done.


Marlene Johnson

2 thoughts on “Preventing LGD Failure – Meeting Your LGD’s Needs”

  1. I do not know if this website is still active, but if so, please respond soon. My husband and I rescued a 5 pound puppy approximately 7 months ago from a homeless man. It turns out this puppy is at least part Anatolian Shepherd, according to our vet. We immediately took him to our vet and began shots as age appropriate, etc. The puppy began to bite and misbehave within two months of our rescue. The first week of this past January we took him to a kennel/trainer and left him for almost a month. He came back with the same behaviors. We wasted a great deal of money and the puppy, Buddy, was now a month older. Buddy now weighs 65 pounds and jumps on us and pulls at our clothing and tries to control us with his mouth. I do not believe he intends to hurt. He just wants what he wants. I think he is in control of us! We love Buddy and most of the time he is a precious dog. We have a huge back yard that is well fenced and we have turned over a large, rarely used bathroom, for his inside kennel. A couple of weeks ago we had him neutered due to it being “time.” We thought that might help with his behavior, but it has exacerbated the situation. He is now taking calming medication every 12 hours, but it is not the solution. We have sought out other training facilities, but we are wary after what we experienced early on. We need help! (We have spent many years rescuing dogs and cats, including black labs, yellow labs, German shepherds, miniature pinchers, terrier mixes, wiener dogs of various sizes, collies, etc., all sizes and ages; however, we have never encountered the situation we are now experiencing.

    1. We do apologize because this post got lost in our system and we missed it. I hope you found the help needed and I suggest looking into an LGD forum on the MEWE social media. They have a great group ran by the author of this article…

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top